Camouflage Book Reviews
Click HERE to return
to the previous page
Phil Peterson, IPMS # 8739
on IPMS/USA website
This is the 2nd eBook provided by Richard Marmo that I have
had the opportunity to review recently.
United States Camouflage WWII, is not a book written by Richard, but
rather is a book compiled and published by Jay Frank Dial in 1964. Richard
restored and enhanced it, and then converted it (with small additions) to
PDF format in 2008. According to the promotional blurb, the original book
has/had been difficult to locate and was expensive when found. I did a
quick search on abebooks and was able to locate a few copies, some cheaper
than others (none cheaper than this eBook). The original book had only one
production run in 1964 and was never reprinted.
Essentially, the original author analyzed and clarified the military tech
orders issued during the war that documented camouflage practices. There
are a few introductory pages explaining how and why he came to publish
this book, and then some 'notes at random' on various interesting colors
and markings. Following this is the meat of the book - namely, the actual
tech orders describing camouflage and markings employed by the USAAF and
USN on aircraft during the war. While the original book had no table of
contents nor page numbers, Richard has thoughtfully added an index that
refers to the page numbers within the Adobe reader. There are still no
labeled page numbers within the book, but within Adobe Reader one can type
in the appropriate page and be brought to that section.
There are pages devoted to any specifics you might need, with the
technical order describing the exact method of application, demarcation,
etc. with respect to camouflage. And more tech orders describing the
insignia styles (with dates of the different types) and application. Here
is an example of the painting directives:
"COUNTER-SHADOWING - the effect of shadows cast by the horizontal airfoils
on certain areas of the fuselage may be minimized by lightening the color
of the areas were they normally fall. The vertical or curved surfaces of
the hull or fuselage between the NON SPECULAR SEA BLUE of upper surfaces
and the NON SPECULAR WHITE of lower surfaces shall be graduated in tone
from NON SPECULAR SEA BLUE to NON SPECULAR WHITE by means of the following
methods:...."
And an example of the insignia directives:
Until 15 May 1942
"The insigne (sp) design shall be a RED circle inside a WHITE five-pointed
star inside a BLUE circumscribed circle. This construction is obtained by
marking off 5 equidistant points on the circumference of the circumscribed
circle and connecting each point to the non-adjacent points. The outer
parts of the lines thus drawn form the outline of a star. The small inner
circle shall be concentric with the larger circle and its circumference
shall be tangent to the sides of the pentagon formed by lines connecting
the inside points of the star." Whew...
As you can see, this is very specific info, and should indeed be very
helpful to any modeler of WW2 US aircraft.
Toward then end of the original publication there are some color chips
which are reproduced here as well. Finally, Richard has added several
photos from his personal collection to illustrate some of the concepts
described in the book.
I did note that it seems much more space is devoted to US Navy schemes,
but I think that can be explained by the fact that the USAAF essentially
went from Olive Drab/Neutral Grey to 'unpainted' with little in-between.
There is, in fact, mention of some of the more obscure USAAF colors such
as sand and sea green, so really this is not a complaint, just an
observation.
Despite its age, I found the information to be very useful. Here is all
you really need to know about US aircraft camouflage during WW2. You can
print out the eBook for your own use, or just keep it handy on the
computer to refer to when needed. I can recommend this without reservation
to those with interest in this area. While I do like the idea of
physically holding a book and turning through the pages, there are times
when an eBook just makes sense. As in "republishing" something that has
long been OOP. This is one of those times, and at the MSRP I think it
represents excellent value.
Thanks to Richard Marmo for offering up the review copy (and for
re-issuing this book!), and to IPMS/USA for allowing me to review it!
|